blogs
Fall from grace, but not from Visa
I laughed out loud when I saw the picture of Michael Phelps, bong and lighter in hand, looking much like, well, like many people in America, particularly young ones.
Then I started following the story, in an attempt to stop following the octuplet debacle in California. And, just as I thought, sponsors stood behind him, while disappointed parents everywhere bemoaned the broken image of their child(rens) "role model."
I even took a few minutes to respond to one hand-wringing mother, that "dreaded" the conversation with her son about his hero's "poor judgment." Get a new hero. A REAL one. Get a better role model, a REAL one.
What seems to be lost in this latest tabloid feeding frenzy is a cold hard look at why we, as a culture, are so sports-crazed, and why we elevate athletes and singers, and, well, ANYONE from Hollywood to the status of "role model."
America loves sports, no doubt about. I love them too, sometimes. After all, I was on a swim team when I was 5, and competed for the next 13 years. But to want athletes and entertainers, people for whom the vast, vast majority of us can never, ever be, to set an example through every one of their actions and words for our children seems to be a bit much to ask. It is more than we typically ask of ourselves, particularly when you factor in the age of some of these stars.
We look, for some reason, to the rarest of the rare to show our children how to live, how to be better people. Why is that? There is nothing particularly balanced about Phelps's - or any high-level athlete's or movie star's life. Every day, every thing they eat, everywhere they go, all of it is determined by the intense demands of their sport and career. They are single-mindedly focused on themselves; they have to be.
Then they become millionaires, the very very few lucky enough to win. Many more academic scholarships are offered than athletic ones, yet parents spend multiple weekends and multiple dollars on their children that participate in sports, hoping for that sports ticket to school.
I feel for Phelps, and any "role model" caught up in this backlash. When he checked off the boxes of the events he was entering last summer, I'm guessing "role model" wasn't one of the choices. He doesn't actually owe us anything. No celebrity does. It is we who put them on a pedestal of our own making, and so it is we who are most disappointed when they stumble at the top. Boycott his sponsors if you truly feel disappointed by him. Have The Talk with your kids about drugs, although it is hard to argue that smoking pot will make you a loser with no friends. It isn't exactly "performance enhancing," unless the performance you seek is to eat an entire bag of chips in .5 seconds.
Or, encourage your kids to look closer to home - and to their history books - for real heroes, real role models. They are all around you. They probably live in your house, stand in front of a blackboard at school, teach Sunday School classes, have overcome true hardship and disability, work every day to make the world they live in a little better, treat their husbands and wives and partners and animals and friends and relatives with kindness and respect.
Let those examples lead the way for your kids, not a 23-year-old athlete at a party. Really.
Leigh appears Fridays on TriangleMom2Mom. Read more about Leigh at her blog Flipper and Me.


Comments
I loved this; great blog.
You have said what I have been thinking...and so much better than I could have!
Thanks to both of you!!
Wow, what a great post. Thought provoking and I totally agree with you.
I just read this morning that Kellogs dropped his contract (http://www.usatoday.com/sports/olympics/2009-02-05-phelps-kellogg_N.htm) and USA Swimming has suspended him for three months (http://www.usatoday.com/sports/olympics/2009-02-05-michael-phelps-suspended_N.htm).
I think you are right on the money about helping kids look for role models outside celebrities and sports. Just become someone is famous we shouldn't assume that they are good role models. People should be role models because of their actions.
I couldn't agree more. He's just a kid, who happens to be a phenomonal swimmer. Nothing more.
Great post. Michael Phelsps is just being 23.
Aside from the swimming prowess, what appealed to me about the Michael Phelps story was his ability to shine at swimming while he struggled with school. It gave him a sense of self worth that he probably did not receive elsewhere.
I love this line in your post:
"It isn't exactly "performance enhancing," unless the performance you seek is to eat an entire bag of chips in .5 seconds."
It made me laugh out loud.
Michael Phelps is an example. He is an example of working hard to make it to the top. He is an example of what it took to get there and the light a person shines when he makes it. Now he is an example of what a person stands to loose from making poor choices. Too many of our young are working hard to make it to the top with no idea why. They believe it is for fame and fortune, an easier ride. They do not realize that the reason behind extra curricular activities is to build teaming skills, build charactor, build confidence. These are traits that will be carried all through life. Children need to know WHY they are working so hard. They need to be shown the big picture from the beginning. They need to know that every step helps them become who they will be even if they make a wrong choice. They need to know where their true joy begins. They need to know how to pick themselves up, brush it off and make correct choices after that. It is our job as parents to show them how to be bigger than a wrong choice. Now is the time for Michael Phelps to show what he is truely made of. He has the opportunity to be a real example. Lets hope he gets it.