blogs

Mean Preschool Girls

Kids are notorious for making inane statements at inane moments. They hold sway over a non-sequitur like nobody's business.

Still, I was ill-prepared for how speedily a recent happy-go-lucky conversation with my 4-year-old daughter devolved into tears. One minute she was prattling on about gymnastics and her new pink Hello Kitty tutu and her latest piece of artwork; the next she was sobbing so hard I could barely make out from whence the sadness came.

I stopped what I was doing – a combination of clearing the table, picking up toys, listening with one ear and inserting the proper “mmm-hmmm’s” to indicate I was paying attention – and scooped her up.

There are crocodile tears and then there are the real deal – and these were authentic. Slowly, shakily, the story spilled out.

Shira had been at preschool, busily crafting paper gingerbread dolls, when a girl in her class told her, “I don’t care about you.” To make matters worse, the girl had the audacity to insist her dolls were “more prettier” than Shira’s.

When it happened, Shira ignored her. She said nothing and told no one. But hours later, the memory surfaced and she started bawling.

She’d gotten her feelings hurt by a Mean Girl.

I couldn’t believe it was starting this early.

In 2002, shortly before I became a mother, Rosalind Wiseman published “Queen Bees and Wannabes: Helping Your Daughter Survive Cliques, Gossip, Boyfriends, and Other Realities of Adolescence.”

Realities of adolescence? Try preschool!

Wiseman’s go-to guide for parents of teen girls laid bare a landscape where girls emotionally bully each other, inflicting social scars that last a lifetime.

As any parent of a little girl can tell you, the social cattiness starts long before high school.

Where some little boys are aggressive, some little girls are passive-aggressive. I’d heard this was true, but this was the first time this phenomenon had confronted me.

“I didn’t tell my teacher,” Shira said to me. “I just wanted to tell my mama.”

Oh, the pressure. My daughter was looking to me for coping mechanisms, and I knew I’d better come up with some good ones.

I put on my child psychologist’s hat. “How did it make you feel?” I asked.

“It hurt my feelings,” Shira answered.

“Did you tell her that?” I inquired.

She answered in a small voice: “No.”

Together, we strategized, with me distilling values like self-confidence to a 4-year-old’s level of understanding and her taking mental notes.

We even practiced. I snubbed her, I punched her (lightly!).

“Fine,” Shira said in her snootiest voice, hands perched on pencil-thin hips encased in above-referenced Hello Kitty tutu. “No one can say something mean to me. No one can hurt me. My body’s special.”

Good job, Mama.

Good job, Shira.

You go, girl.

Bonnie appears Saturdays on TriangleMom2Mom

Bookmark and Share
bonnierochman's picture

Bonnie Rochman

Bonnie is a TriangleMom2Mom featured blogger, appearing every Monday.

She lives in Raleigh and has written for The News & Observer since 1998. She has covered political unrest in the Middle East and chronicled the experiences of entrepreneurs in Vietnam, but that was long before her new bosses -- there are three of them, one more demanding than the next -- presenting her with her most challenging assignment to date: juggling the needs and perceived wants of boy/girl preschoolers and their baby sister.

Bonnie also writes kids music reviews for TriangleMom2Mom. 

Posted on March 21, 2009 by bonnierochman.

Comments

lilybug's picture
by lilybug 8 mon. ago.

My girls all know the mantra in our house, "When other people are unkind, it says EVERYTHING about them and NOTHING about you."

dineer526's picture
by dineer526 8 mon. ago.

Beautiful! And I LOVE lilybug's comment...I'm going to use that! I might have it painted on the wall.

Pamela_DeLoatch's picture
by Pamela_DeLoatch 8 mon. ago.

Oh Bonnie, it almost makes me cry too. They are so young to have to get their feelings hurt like that. And how do girls learn so quickly how to be so hurtful? Well, give Shira a hug from me and tell her we care about her. lilybug-- your mantra has just been inducted into the DeLoatch book of quotes. It's a great one.

heinscoop's picture
by heinscoop 8 mon. ago.

Oh my, it does start early. My daughter is 10 and experiencing some of the worst 5th grade has to offer. According to a website for school counselors, it's called "relational aggression." Around age 10-13, girls use relationships against one another as a form of bullying. In my daughter's case, her 3 closest friends approached her one day on the playground and said they'd all decided not to be her friends any more. Day after day, they said mean things to her, whispered in front of her, and excluded her. She was devastated. For a while, she spent lonely days on the playground and at lunch, which seemed to spur the other girls on. Now she has made new friends, which she catches even more grief for from the original three. But I actually don't think she's being scarred for life. Instead, she is gaining so many important life lessons. She is learning about the importance of making independent decisions -- not following the pack. She has had to step out of her comfort zone and establish new friendships. She has a new understanding of the importance of being polite, not whispering in front of others, not spreading gossip, not talking behind others' backs. This experience has been very painful for my daughter, but it has made her a more compassionate, empathic child. And though we have talked endlessly about it and I have tried to guide her, ultimately, she has figured out how to navigate an ugly situation on her own. She is very proud of herself for that. And she has absolutely amazed me with a grace and maturity beyond her years.

bonnierochman's picture
by bonnierochman 7 mon. ago.

Your must be so proud of your daughter. Growing pains sure can hurt. As for Shira, I'm just so grateful she felt she could tell me what happened. I can only hope that her openness about her feelings continues as she gets older. And Lilybug -- I love that saying!!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

what's happening

santaparade.jpg

Saturday, November 21

The annual parade can run about 2.5 hours. Click here for more information about the Raleigh tr… See details

nasher.jpg

Sunday, November 22

The Nasher Museum of Art opens its doors to families for free. Check out the crafts, a gallery … See details

circusshriner.jpg

Monday, November 23

Amran Shriners present the Royal Hanneford Circus. A second performance is scheduled for 7:30 p… See details

Tuesday, November 24

Listen to stories and sing songs with your child. Tuesdays & Wednesdays at 10 am, weekly until … See details

Wednesday, November 25

Listen to stories and sing songs with your child. Tuesdays & Wednesdays at 10:30 am, weekly unt… See details

 
Powered by the News & Observer