blogs

Trouble in Toyland

Someone's not playing nicely in the sandbox, and it's not little kids this time.

The City of Raleigh is worried about a perceived overabundance of toys in Roanoke Park in Five Points and Pollock Place Park in the University Park neighborhood, situated between Wade Avenue and Hillsborough Street and, as luck may have it, behind my house.

There’s no need for a swingset at home when there’s a park right around the corner. And what is particularly great about my particular park – and Roanoke Park too – is the way the surrounding community has supplemented the city-installed play structures with their gently used and no longer needed toys. Think Little Tikes cars and basketball hoops, baby walkers and soccer balls and a sandbox full of shovels, sifters and dumptrucks.

It’s a kid’s dream.

But now it’s time to wake up.

In August, the toys were removed, ostensibly to protect the children.

Wayne Schindler, the city’s parks superintendent, said this all came about after citizens and staffers who maintain the playgrounds raised concerns. Staff I can understand -- to an extent. But citizens? What citizens? All I’ve heard from them is outrage and disappointment.

The main issue, Schindler explained, is that the playgrounds’ permanent structures need clear “fall zones” to make sure no one gets hurt. That’s according to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Council guidelines for public playgrounds.

But in this case, those federal guidelines are trumping common sense.

“It is very hard to explain to a 2-year-old that a plastic truck that he loves was taken away from the park because it was too dangerous for him,” said Laura Zelinski in a document that defenders of the Roanoke Park toy tradition presented at a meeting last month attended by Schindler and City Council members Rodger Koopman and Russ Stephenson.

If we were playing charades – and I suppose that would be allowed at either park since it involves no sketchy infrastructure – someone would have to act out what feels like just another case of officials legislating for the sake of legislating.

At least at Pollock Place Park, parents and caregivers pretty much took responsibility for ditching any toys that no longer worked or had exposed sharp edges.

If a pushcar lurked beneath the zipline, parents could shove it out of the way.

They made judgment calls about what their kids could play with and what they couldn’t. Those judgment calls were no different than the judgment calls parents make every day regarding a million other issues.

The city is worried about public safety and legal liability. I’m worried about taking the joy out of childhood.

I don’t mean to sound callous to safety concerns. I kept all three of my kids facing backwards in their carseats far past the one-year mark. We live on a busy neighborhood street, and I’ve drilled into my children that no matter how much they love the ball that’s rolled into the street, they are never to chase after it.

But it’s my opinion that parents or caregivers can and should be tasked with making sure their children are playing safely.

The city points out that loose toys are easy to trip over.

You don’t need to tell me that.

I routinely dodge a domestic hodgepodge of baby rattles, elaborately constructed pillow castles and upended laundry baskets doubling as gymnastics equipment.

The emphasis is on the word “dodge.”

If there are toys scattered about, kids are pretty adept at either playing with them or maneuvering around them.

If the city really wanted to make a statement about child safety on playgrounds, they’d fence in the parks’ perimeter. I’ve seen numerous kids make a dash for the street only to be scooped up at the last minute by a breathless mom.

This feels like a case of the city not seeing the forest for the trees, er, toys.

Luckily, some persistent parents have decided to dig in. An agreement that has been drafted allows for specific areas where kids can play with toys.

The agreement faces scrutiny from the Public Works committee and the City Council. If it gets the green light, Schindler said, “then we will draft a policy on how toy play might occur at other park locations.”

Toy play? That sounds so scripted.

I still remember the terror on my mother’s face when she got a call that my brother had fallen from the slide at preschool and needed stitches. It was the kind of slide that many of us recall from our childhood, those towering, silvery inclines reached only by the steepest of metal steps.

Those were dangerous.

A few lovingly donated Cozy Coupes are not.

Bonnie appears Mondays on TriangleMom2Mom.

Bookmark and Share
bonnierochman's picture

Bonnie Rochman

Bonnie is a TriangleMom2Mom featured blogger, appearing every Monday.

She lives in Raleigh and has written for The News & Observer since 1998. She has covered political unrest in the Middle East and chronicled the experiences of entrepreneurs in Vietnam, but that was long before her new bosses -- there are three of them, one more demanding than the next -- presenting her with her most challenging assignment to date: juggling the needs and perceived wants of boy/girl preschoolers and their baby sister.

Bonnie also writes kids music reviews for TriangleMom2Mom. 

Posted on October 6, 2008 by bonnierochman.

Comments

slindenf's picture
by slindenf 1 yr. ago.

Roanoke is my neighborhood park and has been a huge part of my daughter's life. I'm not sure how many times I've had to answer her when she asks why the toys are gone. She actually prefers the playground over at Underwood now. Roanoke is pretty much ruined in her eyes.

ideide's picture
by ideide 1 yr. ago.

Roanoke Park holds so many memories for my boys. Bird mustered up the courage to try a scooter there, which prompted us to buy him one that he has now mastered. Deal plays in the sand for literally hours moving "cement" from one construction site to another. The toys are sorely missed, and my kids have no desire to go to Roanoke Park anymore; partly because the toys are gone and partly because the kids are gone (due to said toys being gone). There is nothing sadder than an old fashioned neighborhood park that sits empty and quiet. Ours is one of few "organic" rather than artificial neighborhoods so it is sad to see its integrity compromised. I see the move as typical by a city that holds little sense of posterity and even less branding for the capital city surrounded by old quaint neighborhoods that it is.

And another thing, it sure is a whole lot greener to donate those cozy coupes to the park than dump them in a landfill.

gigiharrell's picture
by gigiharrell 1 yr. ago.

What a bummer. Please don't let any of the Cary Parks & Rec people read about this. Because before I blink, every sandbox in the town will be missing the "donated" shovels, pails, and various accouterments.

lizacoutu's picture
by lizacoutu 1 yr. ago.

It's too bad they didn't just survey those who used the park to see what they wanted. I'm convinced there is no such thing as common sense these days. It is a lost art.

dineer526's picture
by dineer526 1 yr. ago.

I remember plenty of kids falling off the swings and jungle gyms when I was growing up. Tears dried. Boo-boos healed. Casts eventually came off.

These things will happen in public parks. They will happen at home. A few years ago I cleaned my garage on a rainy day and let my son and his friend ride their scooters around the garage. My son's friend ended up with a broken arm. A year or so later, my son returned the favor, putting his hand through a window at their house, necessitating a trip to the ER and stitches.

I think the toys should be allowed to stay. Parents should be responsible for their own children. If a Little Tykes truck is in the drop zone where your kid is on the swings, get up and move it. Maybe parents need to sign a waiver if they use public parks...no, I will not sue anyone if my kids get hurt here...I hereby accept that S*** happens and sometimes it's nobody's fault.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

what's happening

bonwlogo.jpg

Saturday, March 13

Students will learn the basics of working with clay and glazing while completing a bird house s… See details

Sunday, March 14

LEGO-palooza is back for its sixth year! The N.C. LEGO Users Group will display castles, spaces… See details

Monday, March 15

Weekly BreastfeedingSupport Groups for African American Mothers: Speak with other African Ameri… See details

J4K post card spring2010 fornt.jpg

Tuesday, March 16

Just 4 Kids Consignment Sale March 16th-19th Registration is now open!  Visit our website … See details

 
Powered by the News & Observer